Before making knife , knifemaker always need to evaluate steels and their performance, and decide which steel is suitable for the knife.
Every blade steel undergoes evaluation on the basis of five criteria, each one representing fundamentally desirable attributes that contribute to knife performance. The tests and measurements involved in these aspects of evaluation vary from longstanding laboratory methods to more nearly anecdotal observations based on real-world use.
Hardness—As it applies to steel, the standard laboratory measurement of hardness uses the Rockwell tester and its associated measurement scales to indicate resistance to changes in the shape of materials under impact. For knife steels, the Rockwell C scale provides these indentation resistance values, expressed as numbers followed by the designation “HRC” to indicate the specific Rockwell scale. Rockwell measurements do not correlate with any real-world dimensions. They simply provide indications of hardness that can be used to make comparisons among materials that have undergone comparable testing. Among knife blades, Rockwell measurements commonly range from 56 HRC to 62 HRC.
An alloy’s hardness can vary based on its elemental chemistry and as a result of the heat treatment it receives. Additionally, because many alloys, including D2, list a range of ingredient content for one or more of their component elements, the hardness of one manufacturer’s rendition of an alloy can show performance characteristics that differ from another manufacturer’s equivalent. Likewise, one batch of a steel may differ from another batch.
Toughness—A measure of a steel’s ability ability to bend without breaking and resume its shape without deformation, toughness also correlates with tensile strength. As toughness drops, brittleness rises.
D2 sometimes earns a reputation as a wear-resistant steel that lacks toughness, especially in comparison to other steels that also do not qualify to carry the designation “stainless.” Heat treatment temperatures, the number of tempering steps, and the way the steel is processed between steps can make or break D2’s toughness, potentially bringing it up so it balances with the alloy’s hardness. Blade thickness also plays a role in determining toughness. Thicker blades tend to show less flexibility than thinner blades, and some thin blades fail to return to their original conformation after exposures to bending forces.
To increase the toughness of D2, some steel manufacturers have created versions of the alloy produced through powder metallurgy rather than through conventional steel making procedures. The field of powder metallurgy arose as a response to the negative effects of alloy segregation that appear in traditional alloy manufacturing.
In the time-tested methods of steel production, the producer mixes iron, carbon, and other elements together in an electric arc furnace. This molten material pours into molds that form it into ingots. The act of cooling a large chunk of metal causes its alloying elements to separate, turning what emerged from the furnace as a cohesive, homogeneous mixture into an inconsistent blend. Slicing up an ingot and sampling the chemistry of various parts shows that some areas contain more of an element than others do, with pockets forming throughout the cooled metal. In alloys such as D2, which contain complex mixtures of numerous elements, the resulting steel offers inconsistent performance. Even through post production treatment can overcome some of the effects of segregation, it cannot restore full homogeneity to the alloy.
Powder metallurgy enables finished steel to retain its uniform chemistry and therefore its performance consistency. Instead of creating large ingots, the process miniaturizes the ingot down to the size of a grain of powder. To do so, this advanced production method melts the ingredients of an alloy recipe in a vacuum chamber, and then mists it through a nozzle into a high pressure blast of inert gas. The stream of molten steel turns into tiny droplets, which cool immediately into equally small individual ingots. The powder enters an autoclave in which it undergoes sintering, the combination of heat and pressure, which forms the particles into a solid mass. At the same time, sintering changes the chemistry of the steel, binding elements together at the molecular level. A quenching step rapidly drops the mixture’s temperature, again changing molecular structures to make the combination of elements a permanent state. Low-temperature heat treatment counters brittleness.
Wear resistance—Twin forces conspire to wear away a piece of steel during use. Abrasion removes bits of material from a blade that encounters rough surfaces. Through adhesion, particles detach from other surfaces and attach themselves to blade steel. D2’s performance in the area of wear resistance, its ability to avoid being worn away or falling prey to foreign matter dislodged from other materials, provides much of the basis for its rave reviews as a blade steel.
Remember that D2 was developed as an alloy for use in stamping dies, cutting blades in production equipment, and other metal parts that must repeat a single step under pressure countless times without changing shape. This constellation of attributes explains what attracted knife makers to D2 as a blade steel. Its original use defines and requires considerable wear resistance, an attribute that also contributes to superior blade performance. Even D2 can be outdone in terms of wear resistance, however, by alloys with more complex elemental chemistries and especially by steels produced through powder metallurgy.
Despite the huge advantages of D2’s wear resistance, these strengths also can serve as disadvantages. Specifically, D2 can be difficult to machine and sharpen. Although D2 blades hold their edges through long periods of wear, getting them sharp is a time-consuming task that requires expertise and the right tools.
Corrosion resistance—When a knife blade encounters salt water, acidic liquids such as citrus fruit juice, humid environments, and sustained exposure to moisture, the blade’s corrosion resistance describes its ability to avoid demonstrating pitting and rust. By their very nature, stainless steels are designed to display corrosion resistance, although even a stainless steel will begin to react to corrosive substances after prolonged exposure. Even though D2 does not qualify as a stainless steel, it nonetheless offers better corrosion resistance than many other non-stainless and high-carbon steels can muster.
When corrosion materializes, it begins with the appearance of a patina, a darkening of the surface of the metal. To prevent the development and progression of corrosive effects, a D2 blade should be kept clean and dry, maintained outside of its sheath to avoid exposure to the moisture that can build up in a form fitted leather or thermoplastic storage accessory. A suitable coating of wax also helps forestall corrosion’s ill effects on D2, which can include lowered edge retention along with compromised surface characteristics.
Edge retention—Measurements of edge retention may lack the long history of laboratory quantification and validation that characterize other steel performance criteria such as hardness, but the function of a cutting blade dictates that its ability to stay sharp serves as a basis for evaluating the choice of steel used in creating it. At the same time, a knife that holds an edge through long periods of wear may be the same knife that requires a skilled hand to sharpen effectively and correctly.
Unfortunately, some of these performance criteria compete with one another for supremacy. Hardness often trades off with toughness. As corrosion resistance rises, edge retention can drop, and vice versa. The alloy chemistry that fosters a dominant showing in one area of evaluation can stymie a steel’s ability to compete in another.
The nature of these unavoidable compromises underscores one of the reasons that no single steel presents a commandingly dominant argument to make it the primary, let alone the only, choice for all blades. Of course, some blades are designed to accommodate needs that draw less on some performance criteria than on others. For example, a blade that requires extreme hardness to withstand the pounding impact involved in batoning wood in the field may not require the toughness necessary to survive operations that can cause the blade to bend, or it may survive the bending without breakage but not without becoming permanently deformed.
How is D2?
The following table shows the chemical composition of D2 steel.
|C||1.40 – 1.60|
|Cr||11.00 – 13.00|
|Mo||0.70 – 1.20|
As a word: D2 is High-Carbon, High-Chromium, Cold-Work Steel
D2 tool steels are used for long run tooling applications, where wear resistance is important, such as blanking or making a wear resistance knife.
There are some hot selling D2 knives:
Ganzo Firebird FH71 Carbon Fiiber Folding Pocket Knife with D2 Blade Flipper SystemProduct on sale$28.99 – $29.99
Ganzo Firebird FBKNIFE FH91 D2 blade G10 Handle Folding knife Survival tool Pocket Knife tactical edc outdoor toolProduct on sale
Harnds CK9503 Maverick Folding Knife D2 Blade G10 Handle Ball Bearing Outdoor Hunting Camping Survival Collection Pocket ToolProduct on sale
FREETIGER NEW FT21 Folding Knives D2 Blade Axis System G10 handle EDC Tool outdoor camping hunting Survival tactical knifeProduct on sale
FREETIGER FT903 Model Folding Knife D2 Blade G10 Handle Ball Bearing Outdoor Hunting Camping Survival Tactical EDC Pocket ToolProduct on sale
Ganzo Firebird FH41 D2 Blade G10 Handle Folding Knife Outdoor Survival Tactical Utility Bushcraft Pocket Military New EDC KnifeProduct on sale$27.99 – $28.99
Ganzo Firebird FH11 FH12SS FH13SS Folding Knife with D2 Balde Steel Handle – Flipper Lock EDC ToolsProduct on sale$26.99 – $28.99
Ganzo Firebird FH21 D2 Blade G10 Handle Folding Knife Hunting Survival Tactical Utility Carambit Pocket New Military EDC KnivesProduct on sale